[RRDXA] Contest Code of Ethics by WWROF

["Carsten Steinhöfel"]

Also ich sehe das eigentlich etwa so wie die CQ.

Ich denke:

- Notizen waehrend des Contests (mit Alt-N oder auf Papier) sind OK. Sehe ich als Teil des Logs an.
- Offensichtliche Tippfehler (O statt 0) sind OK. Bei W3LOL in W3LPL wird's schon grenzwertig.
- Audio-Aufnahmen sind nicht OK. Wenn was unklar ist, kann man ja nachfragen.
- Log-Crosschecks mit anderen Stationen sind nicht OK.

Was meint Ihr?

Ausserdem - mir ist das Nachbearbeiten des Logs einfach zu viel Aufwand. Schickt lieber das Log gleich ab und nutzt die Zeit fuer die Vorbereitung auf den naechsten Contest...

73 de Carsten G0SYP


-----Ursprüngliche Nachricht-----
Von: "Maik Reckeweg" <dj2qv at rrdxa.eu>
Gesendet: 21-Oct-2011 12:41:11
An: RRDXA <rrdxa at mailman.qth.net>, BCC <bcc at bavarian-contest-club.de>
Betreff: [RRDXA] Contest Code of Ethics by WWROF

>Hallo Contester,
>
>ein sehr interessantes Thema...
>Wurde ja auch schon in dem CQWW Contest Committe update von K3EST auf
>CQ-Contest angesprochen und vorher kontrovers diskutiert.
>(siehe http://lists.contesting.com/pipermail/cq-contest/2011-October/095883.html)
>
>Ich würde das ganz gerne mal hier zur Diskussion stellen:
>Wie seht Ihr das ? Empfindet Ihr es als "unethisch" sich nach dem
>Contest anhand von Notizen (während des Contests gemacht) und anhand
>von Audio-Aufnahmen (Wintest Contest-Rekorder) einzelne QSOs noch
>einmal anzuschauen bzw. anzhören, und ggf. Tipp- oder Hörfehler zu
>korrigieren ?
>
>73
>Maik DJ2QV
>
>
>
>
>2011/10/21 Walter Skudlarek <dj6qt at t-online.de>:
>>
>>  Hier kann sich jeder mal Gedanken machen...............
>>
>> Walter, DJ6QT
>> -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
>>
>>
>>  CQ WW Director Urges Contesters to Stop Making Post-Contest Log
>>  Changes; "Unsportsmanlike"
>>
>>
>>          *By Jamie Dupree NS3T
>>          <mailto:ns3t%28at%29arrl%28dot%29net>radio-sport.net*
>>          Posted October 20, 2011
>>
>>
>>          As part of the drive to insure "fair play" in ham radio
>>          contesting, top officials from the CQ World Wide Contest
>>          Committee are asking contesters to end the practice of using
>>          outside aid to alter their logs after the contest has ended.
>>
>>          "Your contest result is a measure of your contesting skill,"
>>          argues CQ WW Contest Committee member Doug Zwiebel KR2Q, who
>>          told a recent CQ WW Webinar that it's time to realize that
>>          major changes after a contest is considered outside the bounds.
>>
>>          "CQ WW CC considers the use of post contest data sources as
>>          unsportsmanlike," read one of the slides in Zwiebel's
>>          presentation.
>>
>>          "Part of the CQ WW actions of the Contest Commitee are dealing
>>          with unsportsmanlike conduct," added CQ WW CC Director Bob Cox
>>          K3EST.
>>
>>          "Fair play is a big part of what we do," Cox added.
>>
>>          In a recent post on the CQ-Contest reflector, Cox drove home
>>          the point about post-contest "log cleansing," saying it
>>          clearly runs against the Contester's Code of Ethics.
>>
>>          "I will not modify my log after the contest by using
>>          additional data sources to correct call sign/exchange errors,"
>>          the Code reads.
>>
>>          CQ WW CC officials say they consider it wrong to use "data
>>          sources such as recordings, call sign data bases" and more -
>>          after the contest - to find and correct log errors that
>>          otherwise might be detected by the actual log checkers.
>>
>>          Cox again emphasized the tighter time deadlines for submitting
>>          logs in the CQ WW DX contests, as the period for long
>>          submission was tightened last year - in part to speed up the
>>          processing of the results, and in part to prevent people from
>>          going through their logs with a fine toothed comb to find
>>          mistakes.
>>
>>          The SSB contest log deadline is November 21 - basically three
>>          weeks after the contest. The CW deadline is December 21.
>>
>>          "If you submit a very competitive log, it will be checked in
>>          detail," Cox said in the CQ WW Webinar.
>>
>>          "We're trying to check to make sure verybody receives the
>>          proper awards; it's simple, just follow the rules."
>>
>>          And for the CQ WW Contest Committee, that means once the
>>          contest is over, your log should not be subject to change in
>>          terms of "post-log cleansing."
>>
>>          "The results depend on all of us being honest," said Cox.
>>          "Using undeclared help to find QSO's gives an entrant an
>>          advantage."
>>
>> ______________________________________________________________
>> RRDXA mailing list
>> Home: http://mailman.qth.net/mailman/listinfo/rrdxa
>> Help: http://mailman.qth.net/mmfaq.htm
>> Post: mailto:RRDXA at mailman.qth.net
>>
>> This list hosted by: http://www.qsl.net
>> Please help support this email list: http://www.qsl.net/donate.html
>>
>______________________________________________________________
>RRDXA mailing list
>Home: http://mailman.qth.net/mailman/listinfo/rrdxa
>Help: http://mailman.qth.net/mmfaq.htm
>Post: mailto:RRDXA at mailman.qth.net
>
>This list hosted by: http://www.qsl.net
>Please help support this email list: http://www.qsl.net/donate.html