[RRDXA] Contest Code of Ethics by WWROF

[Maik Reckeweg]

Hallo Contester,

ein sehr interessantes Thema...
Wurde ja auch schon in dem CQWW Contest Committe update von K3EST auf
CQ-Contest angesprochen und vorher kontrovers diskutiert.
(siehe http://lists.contesting.com/pipermail/cq-contest/2011-October/095883.html)

Ich würde das ganz gerne mal hier zur Diskussion stellen:
Wie seht Ihr das ? Empfindet Ihr es als "unethisch" sich nach dem
Contest anhand von Notizen (während des Contests gemacht) und anhand
von Audio-Aufnahmen (Wintest Contest-Rekorder) einzelne QSOs noch
einmal anzuschauen bzw. anzhören, und ggf. Tipp- oder Hörfehler zu
korrigieren ?

73
Maik DJ2QV




2011/10/21 Walter Skudlarek <dj6qt at t-online.de>:
>
>  Hier kann sich jeder mal Gedanken machen...............
>
> Walter, DJ6QT
> -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
>
>  CQ WW Director Urges Contesters to Stop Making Post-Contest Log
>  Changes; "Unsportsmanlike"
>
>
>          *By Jamie Dupree NS3T
>          <mailto:ns3t%28at%29arrl%28dot%29net>radio-sport.net*
>          Posted October 20, 2011
>
>
>          As part of the drive to insure "fair play" in ham radio
>          contesting, top officials from the CQ World Wide Contest
>          Committee are asking contesters to end the practice of using
>          outside aid to alter their logs after the contest has ended.
>
>          "Your contest result is a measure of your contesting skill,"
>          argues CQ WW Contest Committee member Doug Zwiebel KR2Q, who
>          told a recent CQ WW Webinar that it's time to realize that
>          major changes after a contest is considered outside the bounds.
>
>          "CQ WW CC considers the use of post contest data sources as
>          unsportsmanlike," read one of the slides in Zwiebel's
>          presentation.
>
>          "Part of the CQ WW actions of the Contest Commitee are dealing
>          with unsportsmanlike conduct," added CQ WW CC Director Bob Cox
>          K3EST.
>
>          "Fair play is a big part of what we do," Cox added.
>
>          In a recent post on the CQ-Contest reflector, Cox drove home
>          the point about post-contest "log cleansing," saying it
>          clearly runs against the Contester's Code of Ethics.
>
>          "I will not modify my log after the contest by using
>          additional data sources to correct call sign/exchange errors,"
>          the Code reads.
>
>          CQ WW CC officials say they consider it wrong to use "data
>          sources such as recordings, call sign data bases" and more -
>          after the contest - to find and correct log errors that
>          otherwise might be detected by the actual log checkers.
>
>          Cox again emphasized the tighter time deadlines for submitting
>          logs in the CQ WW DX contests, as the period for long
>          submission was tightened last year - in part to speed up the
>          processing of the results, and in part to prevent people from
>          going through their logs with a fine toothed comb to find
>          mistakes.
>
>          The SSB contest log deadline is November 21 - basically three
>          weeks after the contest. The CW deadline is December 21.
>
>          "If you submit a very competitive log, it will be checked in
>          detail," Cox said in the CQ WW Webinar.
>
>          "We're trying to check to make sure verybody receives the
>          proper awards; it's simple, just follow the rules."
>
>          And for the CQ WW Contest Committee, that means once the
>          contest is over, your log should not be subject to change in
>          terms of "post-log cleansing."
>
>          "The results depend on all of us being honest," said Cox.
>          "Using undeclared help to find QSO's gives an entrant an
>          advantage."
>
> ______________________________________________________________
> RRDXA mailing list
> Home: http://mailman.qth.net/mailman/listinfo/rrdxa
> Help: http://mailman.qth.net/mmfaq.htm
> Post: mailto:RRDXA at mailman.qth.net
>
> This list hosted by: http://www.qsl.net
> Please help support this email list: http://www.qsl.net/donate.html
>