[MRIC] RACES 72-hour rule
Pat Scolla
wb0egr at comcast.net
Mon Jul 23 11:43:24 EDT 2007
Brett,
I have spoken to both Mr. Cross and Mr. Hollingsworth on the telephone
in the past about this, and because of the ambiguity in the manner in
which 97.407 is written, the "official" interpretation is going to be a
literal one, and not a "spirit of the law" one.
I believe you have chosen to continue to beat a dead horse unnecessarily
for reasons unknown to me because Joe, AJ3X, sent an e-mail out on the
MRIC reflector on May 11, 2007, in which Mr. Cross agreed that for all
practical purposes it is up to the Emergency Management Agency
responsible for a given RACES group. Why you chose not to accept that
interpretation I do not know.
I can tell you right now that until 97.407 gets changed to reflect what
is happening in the USA today, Mr. Cross and the rest of the FCC will
continue to give a literal interpretation of 97.407 because they have to
and because they do not want to get involved in the inner workings of 50
states, a handful of Commonwealths, and an unknown to me number of
districts and territories.
To briefly go off on a related tangent, in the 36 years that I have been
actively involved in Amateur Radio Public Service Communications
(meaning ARES, RACES, and non-ARES & non-RACES, etc.) around the United
States, I have never seen a place like Maryland where there has been
such a polarization over such a "pain in the rear" rule and a desire by
so few to be "the one in the hot seat" so to speak over who gets to
invoke the 72 hour rule.
The first things I learned with respect to ALL Amateur Radio Public
Service Communications - be it RACES, ARES, SATERN, Red Cross, etc. - is
to check one's ego at the door, to realize that we are there to perform
a service for a client/requester, and to stay out of jurisdictional
politics if at all possible in order to maintain one's professionalism.
Frankly, I do not care one way or the other who has the "final
authority" in Harford County or the State of Maryland when it comes to
the 72 hour rule. All I know is, when my Emergency Manager calls to
activate us for a real incident or an exercise, I'll be ready and if he
asks me to support something in Cecil County, or Kent County, or Talbot
County, or even at MEMA, the Harford County RACES group will do all it
can to fulfill that request.
However, I do care who does and who does not have the authority to
active the RACES group that I "head", and based on everything that I
have heard from not only my Emergency Manager, but also Warren Campbell
and Hank Black at MEMA, that authority rests with the Harford County
Emergency Manager.
So, in order to keep things as simple and as straightforward as
possible, since my Emergency Manager is responsible for giving life to
the Harford County RACES Group, and since he is responsible for
activating the Harford County RACES group, and since he is the one I
answer to about RACES matters, and since he is the one who can
"officially chew my ass out" if I screw up, and since I have heard MEMA
personnel state time and again that "...we are all equals and that no
one RACES group is over any other RACES group...", I'll continue to
recognize my Emergency Manager as the one who has the final authority
with respect to the 72 hour rule, and serve the people of Harford
County, Maryland, and The United States in the true spirit of Amateur
Radio Public Service Communications.
So, to end I ask you this. Don't you think more than enough time has
been spent and wasted on the topic of the 72 hour rule? I certainly
do. Also I would like to ask you this: Is it so unreasonable for us to
believe that the local Emergency Manager's do have the authority to
invoke the 72 hour rule when they, or their designated parties, have the
sole authority to activate us in the first place, and the sole authority
"over us" on every other RACES related issue?
73,
Pat Scolla, WB0EGR
Harford County RACES Officer
Harford County ARES EC
BrettHam at aol.com wrote:
> Pat,
>
> I forwarded your email to Mr. Cross at the FCC for response, and he does not
> want to reply and enter into a debate. He believes he has made it very clear
> that the local jurisdiction needs to get prior approval from the state in
> order to exceed 1 hour. For example, when I asked him in the email below:
>
>
>>> Suppose, instead, I was conducting a local drill just involving Talbot
>>> County, but that exceeded 1 hour per week. Would I also need to get
>>>
> prior
>
>> approval from the state of Maryland?
>>
>
> His response below was "Yes...." and then goes on to support his "yes"
> response.
>
> He also will not address quotes from him taken out of context. And his
> understanding of "state" and "territory" is the same as mine: Maryland is a State;
> Puerto Rico is a Territory (a county is not a territory); Washington DC is a
> District; and Pennsylvania is a Commonwealth. Since we live in a state, we
> must get permission for the appropriate STATE agency responsible for
> emergencies (MEMA) to exceed 1 hour. RACES groups operating anywhere in Districts,
> Commonwealths or Territories need to get permission from their District,
> Commonwealth or Territory level agency to exceed 1 hour.
>
> If you still disagree, I don't know what else to say. I suggest you discuss
> this with your EM and/or his attorney for further clarification.
>
> Brett Hammond - K3TAL
> Chairman, MRIC
>
>
> In a message dated 7/20/2007 11:20:07 A.M. Eastern Daylight Time,
> wb0egr at comcast.net writes:
> Brett,
>
> One, this goes against the concept of "home rule" in Maryland whereby
> the counties and emergency management jurisdictions are "independent"
> and do not need state approval to do something such as invoking the 72
> hour RACES rule. In this case, a county would fall under the
> "territory" terminology that Mr. Cross uses.
>
> Two, I refer you back to the May 11, 2007 e-mail from AJ3X where Mr.
> Cross states "...Because there can be local, state, regional, tribal,
> etc., RACES organizations, the "however" part of your questions isn't
> addressed by the rules. And we aren't going to get into squabbles like
> "then and only then" about "who has authority" between local and state
> level CDOs or what the organization is."
>
> So Brett, until Part 97.407 gets updated so that it no longer reflects
> the "cold war era" where emergency management was the red haired step
> child left to the upper levels of government, then we shall have to live
> with the concept that "...whomever gives life to the RACES group, also
> grants them the 72 hour permissions..."
>
> If MEMA directs Harford County RACES to activate, then they will need to
> ask the Harford County Emergency Manager(s) to activate the RACES group
> within Harford County and explain why because it is the Harford County
> Emergency Management and Civil Government, not MEMA, that allows RACES
> to exist in Harford County.
>
> Oh, and by all means, Harford County RACES will and does fully cooperate
> with any and all other RACES groups in the surrounding jurisdictions
> when there are incidents.
>
> 73,
> Pat Scolla, wb0egr
> Harford County RACES Officer
>
>
>
> BrettHam at aol.com wrote:
>
>> Pat,
>>
>> I believe you are mistaken. In my second email to him, I specifically
>>
> asked
>
>> if I just held a local Talbot County Drill just involving Talbot County,
>>
> do I
>
>> need permission from the state to exceed 1 hour, and Mr. Cross responded
>> "Yes". He said it doesn't matter the scope of the drill, it is only the
>>
> time
>
>> that matters. If you exceed 1 hour per week, you need state permission.
>>
> He also
>
>> specifically said in his first response: "The rule does not allow a local
>> jurisdiction's emergency manager to approve drills and tests that exceed
>>
> 1 hour
>
>> per week."
>>
>> Brett Hammond
>>
>> In a message dated 7/19/2007 10:59:51 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time,
>> wb0egr at comcast.net writes:
>> Brett,
>>
>> To clarify, ONLY in a STATE-RUN Drill, does this apply because the STATE
>> is asking Talbot County RACES to activate. In the case of a Talbot
>> County ONLY exercise, then the 72 hour exception is granted by the
>> Talbot County EM.
>>
>> 73,
>>
>> Pat Scolla, wb0egr
>>
>> BrettHam at aol.com wrote:
>>
>>
>>> Maryland RACES Officers:
>>>
>>> Please find below the complete exchange between the FCC and I to clarify
>>>
>
>
>>>
>>>
>> the
>>
>>
>>> debate we had earlier this year at MRIC about whether or not RACES
>>>
> drills
>
>>> exceeding one hour require state (MEMA) approval. The short answer is
>>>
>>>
>> that a
>>
>>
>>> drill over 1 hour does requires MEMA approval. Please see details below
>>>
>
>
>>>
>>>
>> if you
>>
>>
>>> are interested. Feel free to share this with others, but please do not
>>>
>>>
>> edit
>>
>>
>>> it or excerpt parts. Keep the comments in proper context. Thank you.
>>>
>>> Brett Hammond
>>> Chairman, MRIC
>>>
>>> --------------------------------------------------------------
>>> In a message dated 7/19/2007 3:23:01 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time,
>>> William.Cross at fcc.gov writes:
>>>
>>> Yes--the last sentence of the rule allows exceptions, up to twice a
>>>
> year
>
>>>
>>>
>> and
>>
>>
>>> capped at 72 hours per time, to the hour-per-week rule, when the chief
>>> officer for emergency planning in the applicable State, Commonwealth,
>>>
>>>
>> District or
>>
>>
>>> territory, approves. The rules does not distinguish between local drills
>>>
>
>
>>>
>>>
>> and
>>
>>
>>> state, regional, or some other geographic area drills. It distinguishes
>>>
>
>
>>> between drills that do not exceed 1 hour per week and those that do.
>>>
>
>
>>> -----Original Message-----
>>> From: brettham at aol.com [mailto:brettham at aol.com]
>>> Sent: Thursday, July 19, 2007 2:24 PM
>>> To: William Cross
>>> Cc: Riley Hollingsworth
>>> Subject: Re: RACES 72-hour rule
>>>
>>> Mr. Cross,
>>>
>>> Thank you very much for your prompt response.
>>>
>>> Suppose, instead, I was conducting a local drill just involving Talbot
>>> County, but that exceeded 1 hour per week. Would I also need to get
>>>
> prior
>
>>>
>>>
>> approval
>>
>>
>>> from the state of Maryland? Sorry if this sounds redundant, but I want
>>>
> to
>
>>> make sure there is no confusion. Thank you.
>>>
>>> Brett Hammond
>>>
>>>
>>> -----Original Message-----
>>> From: William Cross <William.Cross at fcc.gov>
>>> To: BrettHam at aol.com
>>> Cc: Riley Hollingsworth <Riley.Hollingsworth at fcc.gov>
>>> Sent: Thu, 19 Jul 2007 11:26 am
>>> Subject: RE: RACES 72-hour rule
>>>
>>> Mr. Hammond:
>>>
>>> Riley asked that I respond to your question. The rule that you are
>>> referring to is Section 97.407(e)(4). It states:
>>>
>>> (e) All communications transmitted in RACES must be specifically
>>>
>>>
>> authorized
>>
>>
>>> by the civil defense organization for the area served. Only civil
>>>
> defense
>
>>> communications of the following types may be transmitted:
>>>
>>> (4) Communications for RACES training drills and tests necessary to
>>> ensure the establishment and maintenance of orderly and efficient
>>> operation of the RACES as ordered by the responsible civil defense
>>> organization served. Such drills and tests may not exceed a total time
>>> of 1 hour per week. With the approval of the chief officer for
>>> emergency planning in the applicable State, Commonwealth, District or
>>> territory, however, such tests and drills may be conducted for a period
>>>
>
>
>>> not to exceed 72 hours no more than twice in any calendar year
>>> (emphasis added.)
>>>
>>> The rule allows a lot of flexibility for management of civil defense
>>> communications at different levels of organization in that it allows
>>> "the responsible civil defense organization served" which, in turn,
>>> depends on how civil defense is organized in a particular area, to
>>> decide what communications RACES stations are authorized to transmit
>>> for tests and drills not exceeding 1 hour per week. The last sentence
>>>
>
>
>>> allows exceptions, up to twice a year and capped at 72 hours per
>>> time, to the hour-per-week rule, when the chief officer for emergency
>>> planning in the applicable State, Commonwealth, District or territory,
>>> approves. Because civil defense was and still is overseen at the
>>> State, Commonwealth, District or territory level, the
>>> Commission decided that the chief officer for emergency planning at
>>> that level should be the one to decide whether exceptions to the the
>>> hour-per-week rule are appropriate.
>>>
>>> In that Talbot County RACES will be participating in the state-wide
>>> DHMH pandemic drill, the "area served" appears to be the State of
>>> Maryland and the "responsible civil defense organization for the area
>>> served" appears to be the DHMH, a state agency, in collaboration with
>>> the Maryland Emergency Management Association. As written, the rule
>>> allows only "the chief officer for emergency planning in the State" to
>>> approve drills and tests in excess of 1 hour per week. The rule does
>>> not allow a local jurisdiction's emergency manager to approve drills
>>> and tests that exceed 1 hour per week. Note that in other paragraphs
>>> of the rule the phrase, "a [or the] civil defense organization" is
>>> used. This is broader than "State, Commonwealth, District or
>>> territory" in that it includes local or national civil defense
>>> organizations, thereby comporting with the definition of RACES in
>>> Section 97.3(a)(37)-- A radio service using amateur stations for civil
>>> defense communications during periods of local, regional or national
>>> civil emergencies (emphasis added.)
>>>
>>> William T. Cross
>>> Mobility Division
>>> Wireless Telecommunications Bureau
>>> Federal Communications Commission
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>
>>
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
>>
>>
>>> --------
>>> From: BrettHam at aol.com [mailto:BrettHam at aol.com]
>>> Sent: Thursday, July 19, 2007 9:53 AM
>>> To: Riley Hollingsworth
>>> Cc: William Cross
>>> Subject: RACES 72-hour rule
>>>
>>> Hello Riley,
>>>
>>> Let me introduce myself: I have a commercial radio license (GROL) and
>>> professionally maintain public safety radio systems in Maryland. I am
>>> also an Amateur Extra and volunteer as RACES Officer for Talbot County
>>> for the past 5 years. I got into amateur and commercial radio because
>>> of my desire to get involved in emergency communications after 9/11.
>>> Prior to that I was a telecommunications software engineer.
>>>
>>> Early this year, the Maryland Emergency Management Association created
>>> a new subcommittee called the Maryland RACES Interoperability Committee
>>> (MRIC), and I was appointed Chairman. It consists of all the RACES
>>> Officers in the state and so far this year we have unanimously agreed
>>> on a standard message form for communicating across jurisdictions
>>> (ICS-213), coordinated all our RACES frequencies, and compiled contact
>>> information for RACES Officers state-wide. We are currently working on,
>>>
>
>
>>> and expect to have completed a state-wide HF RACES net by November (as
>>> a backup to repeaters on towers) and will start work on a state-wide
>>> digital network then.
>>>
>>> Talbot County RACES will be participating in the state-wide DHMH
>>> pandemic drill in two weeks, and will exceed the 1 hour per week
>>> exercise rule. It is my understanding from the FCC rules that we can
>>> exceed 1 hour, two times per year, up to 72 hours each time. I applied
>>> for, and was granted permission from MEMA to exceed 1 hour for the
>>> Eastern Shore Evacuation exercise a few months ago, and was going to
>>> request permission for the Pandemic drill as well, but there was some
>>> discussion from MRIC members that permission from the local
>>> jurisdiction's emergency manager is all that is required (i.e. we do
>>> not need permission from MEMA). Again, my understanding is that the
>>> state, territory, commonwealth, etc, must give permission. Can you
>>> please clarify this for us?
>>>
>>> I will forward this email and your response to all Maryland RACES
>>> Officers so we are all on the same page. Also please tell us about your
>>>
>
>
>>> responsibilities at the FCC so everyone understands your authority.
>>>
>>> Thank you very much for your time. I know you are a busy man, but your
>>> guidance here would help us greatly.
>>>
>>> Brett Hammond - K3TAL
>>> Talbot County RACES Officer
>>> Chairman, MRIC
>>> 410-829-6749 (cell)
>>> _brettham at aol.com_ (mailto:brettham at aol.com)
>>>
>>>
>
>
>
>
> ************************************** Get a sneak peek of the all-new AOL at
> http://discover.aol.com/memed/aolcom30tour
> ______________________________________________________________
> This email list is for the use of RACES Officers and Emergency Managers. Only email related to the Maryland RACES Interoperabilty Committee (MRIC) of the Maryland Emergency Management Association should be sent to this email reflector list. All emails must be in plain text format (no HTML).
> MRIC mailing list
> Home: http://mailman.qth.net/mailman/listinfo/mric
> Help: http://mailman.qth.net/mmmain.htm
> Post: mailto:MRIC at mailman.qth.net
>
>
>
More information about the MRIC
mailing list