[Elecraft] David Cole...756ProIII vs K3

[Gerry Hull]

​My history with amateur radio is that I typically "rent" gear -- what I
mean is I purchase gear new, use it for one or two years, and sell it.
 That way, I get to experience the latest gear without busting the bank
completely.
That has changed since I got my K3.

I'm a contester, CW mostly.   Typically in multi-op stations with big
antennas, amps etc.  So bone-crushing to eme-level signals are the norm.  I
agree with many here that Sherwood has captured a  lot of good data about
receiver performance.  If you want to be a competitive contester or DXer,
your receiver performance is the #1 issue.  Taking a listen doing a couple
of comparisons does not tell a story.  Make sure you understand the tests
that are being described.

I had the FT1KMP and MK5 for a while.   These were the standard for a long
time.  However, the out-of-band, key-click and phase noise issues are
pretty bad.  As was talked about here, the Icom ProII/ III are really good
receivers, but not with out-of-passband spurious products.  Like what was
mentioned by another poster, you never feel you are by yourself with a Pro
III in a contest -- always all kinds of pops an squeaks from out of band
signals.

I think the ergonomic differences between Icom an Elecraft are really not
that great.  They both use single-button overloaded functionality (tap,
single push, push and hold) to provide various functions.  Rather than wrap
things
into the display (limited space), careful labeling on the panel make if
(fairly clear) what is going on.  The comments I get from many older
friends is they don't like this mode of operation.  One friend went out and
bought the 5000 because he did not like the K3 human interface.  Well, he
is selling the 5000.  The K3 receiver, in his opinion, destroys the Yaesu. ​

The reason I'm not going to just "rent" my K3 -- it will be my radio for
the foreseeable future -- goes far beyond the technical performance of the
radio.   It's the intangibles.   The Elecraft team are operators,  They get
it.  They understand who we are and what we want.  They react to our input.
 Have you ever seen a the KIY guys ever react to what the market wants, in
a timely manner?  I don't think so.

I am setting up Remote with some friends -- we had some really strange
issues.  Brandon from Elecraft got on Skype with me from his home, on a
Saturday, to help me diagnose an issue.  What company does that?

I know I'm preaching to the choir on this reflector.  However, when talking
about radios, you cannot leave these details out.  It's what sets Elecraft
in a completely different league from the competition.

73,  Gerry

Gerry Hull, W1VE   | Nelson, NH USA | +1-617-CW-SPARK
AKA: VE1RM | VY2CDX | VO1CDX | 6Y6C | 8P9RM
<http://www.yccc.org> <http://www.yccc.org/>
<http://www.facebook.com/gerryhull>  <https://plus.google.com/+GerryHull/posts>
     <http://www.twitter.com/w1ve>


On Sun, Apr 13, 2014 at 3:11 PM, Dr. William J. Schmidt, II <
bill at wjschmidt.com> wrote:

> There are additional aspects of these comparisons that are not often
> discussed.
>
> The ergonomics of the two radios are vastly different... and rightly so
> given their history.  The Icom has had many more generations of radios to
> improve the look, feel and operation of the radio.  After owning and
> operating both, I find that both have adequate controls places
> appropriately... both radios could improve the menus (cryptic at times).
>
> The other aspect, which is sort of an elephant in the room is the repair
> histories and the way repairs are handled by the respective companies.
>  I've never had a repair issue with my PRO III, although I have sent my
> 7800's back for service twice.  It this case the radios sat in a queue at
> ICOM repair depot waiting for their turn to get fixed.  Several weeks later
> the radios arrived without any warning, to sit out on my doorstep awaiting
> my arrival home.  In contrast, I've had three issues with my K3... all
> three were diagnosed over the phone with tech support and parts shipped to
> me for install and immediate correction of the issues.  While the K3 record
> on failures seems a bit higher than the Icom, the relative ease of
> troubleshooting and repair for a person like me (will full lab/ repair
> capabilities) is a wonder.
>
> Neither of these things should be missed when contemplating a new radio.
>
>
> Dr. William J. Schmidt - K9HZ / J68HZ/ 8P6HK/ ZF2HZ/ PJ4HZ/ VP5HZ
>
> Owner - Operator
> Big Signal Ranch
> Staunton, Illinois
>
> email:  bill at wjschmidt.com
>
>
>
> ______________________________________________________________
> Elecraft mailing list
> Home: http://mailman.qth.net/mailman/listinfo/elecraft
> Help: http://mailman.qth.net/mmfaq.htm
> Post: mailto:Elecraft at mailman.qth.net
>
> This list hosted by: http://www.qsl.net
> Please help support this email list: http://www.qsl.net/donate.html
> Message delivered to gerry at w1ve.com
>