[Elecraft] CW - SS - Off Topic

[N2EY at aol.com]

In a message dated 11/11/04 8:26:30 AM Eastern Standard Time, kb6nu at w8pgw.org 
writes:


> I really have to disagree.  I advise those getting started with CW to not
> bother trying to master a straight key before beginning to use a keyer. I
> just don't see how learning to send with a straight key helps anyone send
> better with a keyer, and if they're going to eventually use a keyer, why not
> just start out with one?

It has to do with developing rhythm and timing. While the keyer requires a 
different motion and timing than a straight key, the basic mental 
concepts/skills are best laid down with the straight key. IMHO.

> 
> Unless you really enjoy using a straight key, I think it's a disincentive.

Why? 

> It's certainly harder on the wrist. Remember, we're talking about a hobby
> here, and a hobby is supposed to be fun. If it's not fun to work CW, fewer
> guys are going to operate CW. I'd rather have more CW ops using keyers, than
> a few die-hards pounding straight keys.

I'm not saying everyone *must* use straight keys, just that it's a good idea 
to *start out* with one to develop the skills and timing.

In my experience, those who start out with straight keys actually have an 
*easier* time learning to send good CW - with straight key, bug, or keyer of any 
variety.

73 de Jim, N2EY



> 
>