[Dx-qsl] Re: SWL data is correct, but

[Masa/JG1OWV]

Thanks many responses.

I strongly believe there was NO cluster spot, even in JA local one.
Already checked before posting to this reflector.

Then grey line is one suggestion, but, you know, path between F and JA
on 80m is quite difficult.
I don't hear nor see any JA was working with continental zone 14 during 
our sunset.  Instead it's our time to work USA.
Maybe more EU's give me more idea about this reality of grey line path
on that time.

On his SWL card,  Ant :Cushcraft
I could not either believe he heard my partner's signal.
So another mystery is how he could know my QSO?

Assuming he is not honest, the final question is why he needs just
my JA QSL?  
I can't find any reason for him to cheat and have JA QSL.
Some private reply mails to this reflector move my mind.
At least, this guy has an interest on a low band CW !
This is enough to believe that he is a very professional SWL, reporting
incredible path which hams cannot find out through contest crowd!

My conclusion is  I WILL QSL to him.
Thanks many for their precious opinions.
SWL report is always welcome!
CU on air.

Masa / JG1OWV



----- Original Message ----- 
From: "Masa/JG1OWV" <jg1owv at jarl.com>
To: "DX- QSL" <dx-qsl at mailman.qth.net>
Sent: Friday, February 23, 2007 11:17 PM
Subject: SWL data is correct, but 


> Hello OMs, I need to consult you.
> 
> Today French SWL card comes to me through bureau,
> trying to confirm my 3.5MHz CW signal at 2005 WW-CW.
> Time is 0844Z and my QSO partner is HL station.
> All the data on this SWL card are correct against my log.
> 
> However, I am not a big gun running only 150W and never
> even hear any F signal on 80m until now.
> At the best of my knowledge, I suspect any French station
> has almost no possibility to hear my signal at 0844Z on bottom
> of November with WW contest QRM within Europe. 
> 
> Do you DX'ers recommend me to send my confirmation
> QSL card to this SWL station?
> 
> Masa / JG1OWV