[Yaesu] Yaesu FT920 vs Icom 746: Results of comparison

W8OKN Sean w8okn at charter.net
Thu Nov 1 16:57:22 EST 2007


Perhaps I should explain myself further...

I am reading from the QST articles that compare the two rigs.  The 
comparisons are close (closer than not) and there are many external factors 
that can have a significant impact on even side by side comparisons.  This 
is why we have laboratories.

And again, I really do appreciate the report, but we should not, as 
technicians and engineers, forget that the test can be misleading, if not 
completed properly.  Not that there was any bias, but even when we honestly 
approach something like this, we can subconsciously overlook things or miss 
important factors.

This is not a critique of the method used, nor a critique of the tester, but 
simply an editorial comment about the methods we choose to conduct tests and 
do comparisions.

Perhaps it would be better to say, "I like the 920, and here is why."    If 
you went to the Icom 746PRO thread, you would have someone there give a list 
as to why the 746PRO is better, and so forth.

Oh... and ...  No, I do not want more noise.

W8OKN 



More information about the Yaesu mailing list