[TheForge] Meteoric iron - wrap it in foil

Andy Vida osan at netlabs.net
Sun Jun 13 00:10:51 EDT 2004



Ralph E Douglass wrote:

> I think you need to step back a bit there lady.

	Perhaps we all should.  This has gotten touchy and why
	pursue it?  There are enough bad feelings in this world
	as it is.

> I did not see him as attacking your choice in religion at all. It seemed
> to me he was commenting on the bit about how you were just wanting to
> make a commision on the item and you did not care as to how it was to be
> used. His comment was trying to say if he made bomb parts and sold them
> it mattered not to who as he did not care as to how 'they' planned to
> use them.

	These brands of reasoning get very cumbersome, especially
	when taken to the reductio ad absurdum, which in this case
	would reduce to nobody being able to sell anything to anyone
	because just about anything you care to name can be used to
	fashion a weapon which may in turn be used unjustifiably
	against one person by another.  It is a fallacious argument
	and must be seen as such, lest we get ourselves bogged down
	in some seriously flawed thinking.
> 
> To be honest this is one of the biggest arguments as to why I personally
> do not make knives for sale. I will make them as gifts for good friends.
> But that is me and I am not trying to tell others how to live.

	And that is fine. :)

	Can we all kiss and make up now?  Kissing's a whole lot
	more fun than fighting.

	-Andy


More information about the TheForge mailing list