[R-390] Replacing carbon comps with metal film resistors

[James A. (Andy) Moorer]

Every time I have done this test (in the context of pro audio), the 
metal films won hands down. My problem with using them for boatanchors 
is that they are hard to find in high wattages (above 1/2 W) and high 
resistances (above maybe 470K). They are out there, but just hard to 
get. And waaaay more expensive than comps.
-A


-- 
James A. (Andy) Moorer
www.jamminpower.com

On 7/29/2019 11:50 PM, Jacques Fortin wrote:
> Hi Perrier, Bob, and everyone else
>
> This is an experiment I performed a lot of times before, but just to check again....
>
> The Q swamping resistors inside several R-390A IF transformers are 39K, 10%, 1/2W, carbon composition...
> I opened my parts drawer for resistors of that value, and waked up my old trusty Hewlett-Packard 4192A LF Impedance Analyser.
> And there are the values I measured for various resistors types at 455kHz (all those being rated at 1/2W) with the minimum connecting lead lengths by using the HP 16047C Test Fixture.
>
> But just before you look at those results....
> I hope that everyone remembers that in the equivalent serial representation, an impedance is a value of pure resistance, plus or minus a reactance.
> Meaning, Z = R ± j X
> If the measured reactance is positive, you have an inductance in series with the resistive part, and if it is negative, you have capacitance in series with the resistive part.
> In theory, a perfect resistor will exhibit a measured reactance of ZERO, or, expressed otherwise, smaller is the measured reactance, more the part is close to the perfect model.
>
> Ohmite Carbon Composition:
> 40100 -j 1370
>
> Philips Carbon Film:
> 38710 -j 950
>
> Sanyo Carbon Film:
> 38850 -j 780
>
> Corning Glass Works (CGW) Metal Oxide Film:
> 39470 -j 870
>
> Philips Metal Film:
> 38980 -j 400
>
> In this test, at 455kHz, the metal film resistor wins.
> But the surprise is that the Carbon Composition turned out to be the more "imperfect" of the lot !
>
> 73, Jacques, VE2JFE
>
> ______________________________________________________________
> R-390 mailing list
> Home: http://mailman.qth.net/mailman/listinfo/r-390
> Help: http://mailman.qth.net/mmfaq.htm
> Post: mailto:R-390 at mailman.qth.net
>
> This list hosted by: http://www.qsl.net
> Please help support this email list: http://www.qsl.net/donate.html