[R-390] OT: Wet or Solid Tantalum?

Barry n4buq at knology.net
Mon Nov 10 11:03:25 EST 2008


Tim wrote:

> 1 Amp is a high current drain for a LM317. If the voltage drop is
> anything more than a few volts you'll need heatsinking.

I'm planning on using a pass transistor and heatsinking both devices.  I ordered a couple of heatsinks but on the advice 
of another list member, am looking for something more substantial and think I've found it.

> As a small hint, if you're paying 20 times for a bypass capacitor for a
> device than the device itself costs, something's out of whack in the design. It's like
> discovering the steering wheel for your Ford Escort costs half a million dollars and is
> solid gold.

That seems to be what's going on here.  I put my money into the transformer, rectifiers, and filter caps.  I just wanted 
to make sure that if I didn't go with the solid tantalum, the regulator would still perform properly (e.g. not break into 
oscillation, etc.).

Sorry for the OT bandwidth guys.  I need to shut up and just build the stinkin' thing...

Thanks again,
Barry



More information about the R-390 mailing list