[R-390] Subject: Off list posts

[Barry Hauser]

Bob Camp says:
> I would *much* rather
> have the activity we have here (and the repetition) in stead of the dead /
> no traffic situation that seems to go on with so many other specialized
> lists.

Me too!  Excessive bandwidth conservation = DBS -- Dead Band Syndrome.

Here's another thing or three:  Replying off-list to posts can be, in
effect, inconsiderate or just plain "chicken".  The inquiring pilgrim may
get a lot of redundant, but uncoordinated answers that may seem
contradictory or disjointed.  The individual respondents aren't aware that a
particular suggestion was already given.  It's also wasteful of the other
listmembers' time taken to reply with an answer that's already been given
privately.  Finally, it's a way to conveniently avoid rebuttal, correction,
clarification, alternate opinions, etc. -- hence the chicken-factor.

OK, so a few dead horses get beaten.  The vet says it's good for their
circulation.

So, unless there's a good reason -- like "I'll buy it!" or "Do you take
Paypal?  Green Stamps?" whatever, I vote for "Reply All".

Only one problem.  I've got a nail stuck in my foot from this soapbox I'm
standin' on. ;-)

BTW --  Happy New Year
Barry