Jim,

 Ah ha! Just as I suspected. A holding magnet would need some mechanical help to get pulled in.
I for sure am dealing with a pulling magnet.
That just leaves me with one question. Does the pulling magnet operate on 60mA?

Thanks,
-Steve

On Monday, January 20, 2025 at 10:53:59 AM EST, Jim Cooper <[email protected]> wrote:


On 20 Jan 2025 at 13:23, steve bennett via GreenKeys

wrote:

> How do I know if my M15 is using a pulling magnet vs a holding
> magnet?Why do the two variations exist?


There is a very serious difference between the two types
of selector magnets ...  the Holding type actually has a cam
on the main shaft that pushes the armature against the sel.
magnet core, this avoiding the need for the magnetism from
the loop current to do all that work of moving the armature;
the PULLING magnet needs a lot of magnetic power to pull
that armature from resting [space] up against the magnet
core [mark]...  so clearly the Holding magnet is preferable !!

But you don't really have a choice on any one machine,
because without that cam on the main shaft you don't
have the push for the holding magnet.

w2jc