[Elecraft] New K3 built - can I reset the 5w calibration?

Edward R. Cole kl7uw at acsalaska.net
Sat Dec 10 18:41:20 EST 2011


I've been reading the comments about Bird43 accuracy for awhile, but 
the claim that the error is fixed amount for all levels of power 
measured on a given element just does not agree with my 
experience.  (Just about) ALL of my RF power measurements have been 
using the Bird and what I see is a scaled error and not a fixed 
one.  If the full scale reading is off 5% then the quarter power is 
likewise 5% off.  In other words 100w measured with a 100E element at 
432-MHz might actually  be 95w.  If I measure 50w with the same 
element the actual power will be about 47.5w.  25w will be about 
24w.  I'm not saying the accuracy tracts exactly linearly with power 
level but it seems approximately so.

That being said, the accuracy for measurements at under 25% of the 
full power rating of the element is not of much value except as a 
relative number.  I try to chose an element so the meter reads >70% 
full scale for best accuracy and resolution if I am trying to obtain 
absolute power measurements.

If I want better accuracy I use calibrated attenuators with my HP432A 
microwave power meter (10-MHz-18-GHz) which measures -20 to +10 
dBm.  I have two high-power 20-dB coax attenuators: 100w NARDA (good 
to 4-GHz) and 10w Bird (good to 1-GHz).  I measured the Bird on a 
steady 2m signal yesterday and it is exactly 20 dB within the 0.2 dB 
resolution of the HP meter.  For measuring 300w on 1296 I have some 
40 and 50-dB directional couplers from the cellular industry (rated 
for high power).  That permits power measurements to be made with the 
HP power meter (300w = +55 dBm => -50 dB = +5 dBm)  2:1 SWR reflected 
power would be 30w (+ 45 dBm +> -40dB = +5 dBm).  But this also 
allows me to check the accuracy of the Bird power meter.  I suspect 
this is "good enough" for ham radio purposes.


73, Ed - KL7UW, WD2XSH/45
======================================
BP40IQ   500 KHz - 10-GHz   www.kl7uw.com
EME: 50-1.1kw?, 144-1.4kw, 432-QRT, 1296-?, 3400-?
DUBUS Magazine USA Rep dubususa at gmail.com
======================================



More information about the Elecraft mailing list