[Elecraft] Curious 1% Resistors
Bob Alkire
[email protected]
Thu Oct 10 13:10:01 2002
> As I'm sitting here stuffing resistors into my K2 (#2862) rf board, you
>know that big long tape that seems to go on forever, I started to
>wonder. Has anybody replaced the 5% resistors with 1% resistors to try
>to enhance or make their K2 the best one on the block.
>Just curious, as you know a 1k 5% resistor can range from 950 to 1050
>ohms, while a 1k 1% could vary between 990 to 1010 ohms. Would that
>make any difference or would be like hanging fuzzy dice from the rear
>view mirror and putting chrome wheels on your 1970 Pinto station wagon
>and expecting your time in the 1/4 mile drag race to improve?.
I think your analogy is accurate with the fuzzy dice.
If "Waric" (Wayne/Eric), had needed to use 1% in their design, they would
have used them - the cost difference is not that great. In a design, all
that may be required to meet a minimum current flow and the resistance
tolerance can be quite large. Using 5% rather than a 1% is bit of
information to the schematic reader that perhaps a resistance is needed to
provide minimum current flow and can have more resistance tolerance . If
you are designing with a resistor divider which requires accuracy with
closer tolerance and more values, than 1% and 0.1% become necessary.
I use a free program for picking divider resistors from this guy:
http://bleverett.home.att.net/
He came out with a windows version which broke on my Win2K system and I
suggested coming up with a command line version: which he did. It compiles
on Linux and Cygwin.
If you want to "hop up" your k2, there are plenty of mods out there at the
elecraft site and http://www.qsl.net/la3za/K2/mod.html. Many are
professionally documented and quite well done.
Anyway, my "chrome wheel mod" was changing the spinner knob, which was beat
to death a while back on the reflector.
Cheers - regards - 73's
Bob AF6J