[Dxbase] DXCC Award Submission puzzle

[Ron Stordahl *]

Trying to understand the DXCC awards submission I have simplified the 
selection criteria to run this test:

Output>Awards>DXCC and in that window I select:  DXCC Award Type: 10 
meters.  Additional selections are QSO Log, Cards Only, Exclude Past 
Submission, Select Only valid for field check, combine RTTY and Digital, 
Exclude QSO's before 19451115.

With these selections I should only generate a list of Cards needed for 
the 10 meter award which are not already credited.

The result is 15 selected cards. 

The first is XF4MX 10 03 1999 10 CW Revilla Gigedo. 

Checking what DXBase2007 has recorded as credited I run the report 
"Arrl_hardcopy_style_DXCCawardcreditsliting.rpt"

That report indicates for XF4 the following awards credits:  Mixed, 
Phone, CW, 40, 20, 15, 10.  Thus I already have 10 metered credited 
which should mean that no new card is needed for just the10 meter 
award.  Checking what DXBase has credited for 10 meter award I find this Q:

XF4CI 27 12 1993 10 USB Valid=Mixed+Mode, Award=DXCC, Select=null.

Since the individual band modes for DXCC awards are not endorsed by 
mode, this  existing credited Q is all that is needed for 10 meters.  
Submitting a second card will be useless.

Additional information: I find that there is a CW card already credited 
XF4MX 06 03 1993 15M CW (obviously an earlier dxpedition by XF4MX), thus 
no new card for the CW award is needed either.  But in any case I didn't 
select awards for CW DXCC only for the single band 10 meter award.

I now check the additional 14 cards on the generated list, all of them 
are Phone Q's, and not one of them is actually needed for the 10 meter 
award, each of these entities have previously been credited with CW 
cards for the 10 meter award.

I deselected 'field checking' just in case, but it made no difference, 
the same 15 cards were selected...they were already all within the 10 
year window.

So to review:  The DXCC single band awards are not mode dependent or 
endorsable, thus if you have credited a Phone Q for that entity, 
submitting a CW card later will not make any change in your count 
(credit) for that award.

I think I understand the DXCC rules in this regard, leading me to 
suspect the selection module is picking unneeded cards.

Of course it was not my intention to just submit for the 10 meter award, 
I actually had initially selected Mixed, Phone, CW, RTTY, 80, 40, 30,20, 
17, 15, 12 and 10.  It was there that I could see that cards were being 
selected which were unneeded, but the problem is essentially the same, 
cards are being selected which are unneeded..and lots of them!  So to 
use the module I apparently need to review it's output and remove lots 
and lots of cards.  It shouldn't be this way.

I won't mind in the least if the error is on my part, as long as someone 
can point out the error in my analysis.

Ron, N5IN