[Dx-qsl] My QSL Service

Chris Codella, W2PA w2pa at arrl.net
Wed Nov 28 09:54:27 EST 2007


Sounds like a reasonable idea, if all you need is a QSL for display.  
The biggest problem has to do with acceptance for awards (as Dave also 
pointed out).

w4sco at sco-inc.org wrote:
 >This idea is no different than if you prepare a card at your qth...
 >Print it out on your printer, fill in the other ham's qso details, then
 >put that card into an envelope and post it to them.

But there is one big difference pertaining to authentication.  If you 
mail it, the card has your original signature on it that was not 
produced by a printer.  Likewise when a QSL manager sends out a card it 
usually has some sort of authenticating stamp applied by hand.  If this 
kind of authentication is missing, how can anyone tell that the 
receiving operator hasn't simply fabricated the DX card themself?  A 
picture or re-creation of a signature or stamp is not the same thing as 
the signature or stamp itself.  The former can only be created by the 
originating operator - the latter can be created by anyone with a printer.

Even for display purposes, I'm not sure I'd want to display QSLs I 
printed myself on my own printer - any more than I'd want to display a 
fax or photocopy of a diploma or an award.

This is the same problem e-qsl has.

73,
Chris




More information about the DX-QSL mailing list