[Boatanchors] UNSUBSCRIBE

[Bill Martin - K4SGF]

  ----- Original Message -----=20
  From: Gary Schafer=20
  To: Glen Zook=20
  Cc: Duane Fischer, W8DBF ; Arthur Shulman ; Telegrapher@QWEST.net ; =
boatanchors@mailman.qth.net=20
  Sent: Friday, March 15, 2002 11:09 AM
  Subject: Re: [Boatanchors] new Ground system


  I was afraid you were going to say that Glen. I would bet you 10:1 =
that
  your tower has been hit many times given the location that you =
describe
  it is located in. It sounds as though you have very good grounding
  installed. That is the key to keep from damaging things. As far as the
  dissipation devices go, I don't know how to put it any nicer, they are
  snake oil.

  There is no way to "bleed of the charge". This is an old myth and it =
has
  been propagated by the manufacturers of the dissipation arrays in the
  past several years.
  If you will notice that in their installation instructions that they
  recommend quite extensive grounding to make them "work properly". =
Wonder
  why?

  The thing is that the earth can supply hundreds of times more energy
  much faster than it can be bled off.


  NASA and the FAA tested some of dissipation devices extensively a few
  years ago and determined that there was no difference in the number or
  severity of strikes with or without the dissipation arrays. I have =
some
  video tape of some test's that the FAA did on one of their towers
  showing an actual strike hitting the dissipation device.

  If you want to find out how often your tower really gets hit you can
  install a simple lightning strike counter. You can make one with a =
small
  veeder root counter that is activated by a coil. Put an mov across the
  coil to keep from cooking it. Hook one lead to any point on a tower =
leg
  and go up several feet and hook the other lead. During a strike the
  current that is developed across the section of tower leg will trip =
the
  counter one count. Polyphaser sells such a device for that purpose =
also.

  There is no way to prevent a lightning strike. There are however many
  ways to control the strike current once it does hit.

  I have a few notes about lightning protection that I posted to another
  group awhile back if there is interest here.

  73
  Gary  K4FMX


  Glen Zook wrote:

  > My tower has NEVER been HIT by lighting.  However,
  > there is more to this than just grounding.  You have
  > to use dissipation devices as well.  Those can be made
  > for under $10 apiece (one is needed for each leg of a
  > tower, and if the tower is over 100 feet tall, they
  > should be placed from 50 to 75 feet apart up each
  > leg).  Or, you can buy them commercially built for
  > about $350 apiece!
  >
  > A dissipation device will not protect a tower 100%
  > from a strike (nothing can).  However, they can reduce
  > the chances of a strike up to 99.99%.
  >
  > Glen, K9STH
  >
  > --- Gary Schafer <garyschafer@attbi.com> wrote:
  > > Glen,  are you saying that because of your grounding
  > > system that your
  > > tower has never been hit by lightning? Or that you
  > > have never had any
  > > damage from a lightning strike.
  >
  > __________________________________________________
  > Do You Yahoo!?
  > Yahoo! Sports - live college hoops coverage
  > http://sports.yahoo.com/

  _______________________________________________
  Boatanchors mailing list
  Boatanchors@mailman.qth.net
  http://mailman.qth.net/mailman/listinfo/boatanchors



--- StripMime Report -- processed MIME parts ---
multipart/alternative
  text/plain (text body -- kept)
  text/html
---