[Antennas] Tarheel Model 200 or High Sierra HS-1800DX ?

[WD8ARZ]

I am on the verge of buying either the Tarheel Antenna Model 200 Screwdriver
antenna  http://www.tarheelantennas.com , or the High Sierra Screwdriver
Antenna Platinum Deal with the HS-1800DX http://www.cq73.com/ .

Anyone with any experience to share with the rest of us on the choice that
they would go with based on performance and survivability, not just cost?

Thank you in advance!

73 from Bill - WD8ARZ
wd8arz@ix.netcom.com