[1000mp] ARRL data - 1 kHz IMD and BDR performance
Bill Tippett
[email protected]
Thu, 29 Jan 2004 18:32:38 -0500
For my own curiosity I decided to look at 1 kHz IMD and BDR
performance using the swept graphs in ARRL's Expanded Test Reports.
I confirmed with KC1SX who does ARRL's tests that the closest signal
spacing was at 1 kHz in the swept IMD and BDR graphs (typically
found around page 20 of the ETR reports). Why 1 kHz? Because in a
typical contest, it is not unusual for strong interfering signals to be
spaced at 1 kHz or even closer. Also, it is not simply two strong
interfering signals...many weaker ones can contribute to the problem.
"Always remember actual overload is the result of the vector sum of
signals in the passband of the system at that point. One way to look
at it is that overload is an accumulated power problem, not an
absolute level problem with one signal. This means a great number of
weaker signals can cause the same problem as a few strong ones."
http://www.w8ji.com/how_to_check_signals.htm
The only exception to 1 kHz measurements below is for the
original MP, done in 1996 before KC1SX took over ARRL's testing.
Listed in order of 1 kHz IMDDR3 results:
Radio IMDDR3 BDR
TT Orion 84 dB 119 dB
FT-1000MP* 78* 108*
IC-756PRO 75 104
IC-775DSP 73 103
TT Omni VI+ 71 85
IC-746PRO 70 92
IC-746 70 88
IC-756PRO2 69 92
FT-1000MkV 69 100
Elecraft K2 66 115
TS-870 63 87
FT-1000Field 60 88
JRC NRD-535 50 86
IC-756 50 85
*FT-1000MP IMD @ 2 kHz and BDR @ ~500 Hz
Source: http://www.arrl.org/members-only/prodrev/reports.html
73, Bill W4ZV